Case Summaries
The Supreme Court of Bermuda COMMERCIAL COURT APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Environmental
THE BERMUDA ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY TASKFORCE vs. THE MINISTER OF HOME AFFAIRS
The case concerns appeals related to decisions on environmental planning permissions for land reclamation and development for the America?s Cup Event Village and a Commercial Marine Facility and Marina focusing on environmental assessments consultations and planning permissions processes.
2015
Supreme Court of Bermuda Commercial Court Civil Jurisdiction
Employment
Allison Thomas v. Fort Knox Bermuda Ltd Troy Symonds Shari Poe
Thomas former COO of Fort Knox terminated with immediate effect one month s salary in lieu dispute over implied term of reasonable notice and breach of Employment Act
2009
Court of Appeal for Bermuda
Family
Georgia Marshall & Rachael Barritt v. A
Allegation of conflict of interest due to possession of confidential financial information by the first appellant leading to an injunction restraining both appellants from acting further in proceedings between the respondent's husband and his former wife
2015
Supreme Court of Bermuda
Civil
Carl Paiva v. Hamiltonian Hotel & Island Club Ltd.
The Plaintiff Carl Paiva seeks an injunction against the Defendant for a public nuisance claim related to an unsafe retaining wall on the Defendant's property posing a hazard. The wall adjacent to the public roadway Ocean Lane and opposite Paiva's properties is at risk of imminent collapse endangering users of the roadway including children. The Defendant Hamiltonian Hotel & Island Club Ltd. failed to repair the wall despite acknowledging the need.
2007
COURT OF APPEAL (CRIMINAL DIVISION) SUPREME COURT OF BERMUDA
Criminal
Kiari Tucker v The Queen
On 13th June 2019 Kiari Tucker was convicted for the murder of Morlan Steede and using a firearm to commit an indictable offence. Tucker was sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder with a recommendation of 25 years before eligibility for parole and 10 years' imprisonment for using a firearm to run consecutively. The appeal focuses on both conviction and sentence. The facts involve Tucker after premeditation chasing and fatally shooting Steede on 3rd November 2017. CCTV footage captured the chase and shooting. After the murder Tucker made an 83-second call that coincided with a group outside Spinning Wheel night club receiving news about the murder. Tucker was arrested the next day. Forensic evidence linked Tucker to the murder including gunshot residue particles on his hands and clothing. A forensic gait analysis expert testified to the similarities in gait between Tucker and the assailant captured on CCTV.
2020
Supreme Court of Bermuda
Civil
Natalie Chiranji Kevin Gregory Bean and Thaddeus Arthur Hollis III (as trustees of the Jack Daniels Trust) v. John Andrew Bento (in his personal capacity and as trustee of the Alanton Trust) and Esther Bumatay Bento (as trustee of the Alanton Trust)
Defendants failed to complete the sale of property units leaving them unfinished and departing jurisdiction leading to Plaintiffs' claims for damages declarations and interest
2008
- 145Page 8
EPHESIANS 6:16
Hindsight law can make mistakes. Consider checking original case studies